How We Test
We aggregate millions of product reviews, scour other websites for their professional opinions - then we test the products ourselves. We do not accept free products from manufacturers, and our only goal is to give you the best recommendations possible. However, if you buy from the links on this page, we may earn a small commission.
- Best Fanny Pack - July 25, 2024
- Best Whole30 Snacks - July 25, 2024
- Best Toys For 4 Year Old Boys - July 25, 2024
There are dogs that naturally have a calm demeanor, and then there are the heavy chewers. While aggressive chewing could be caused by teething, anxiety, lack of mental stimulation, or just an inability to gauge their own strength, the reality remains that if you have a dog that really loves to chew, “regular” dog toys are just not going to cut it.
You’ll only end up with stuffing, squeakers, and mysterious fabric remnants scattered amongst your floor, which can also be a health hazard for your favorite creature. But don’t worry – we’ve done the legwork for you and have found the best indestructible dog toys.
No more mess, no more wasting money on toys your best friend is destined to destroy. We looked at a wide range of toys that are both high-quality and designed for our precious, loving, aggressive chewers. Here are our top picks.
Our Top Pick
Chuckit! Ultra Ball Dog Toy
With over 14,000 positive reviews, this ball will make your dog very happy. And with a super low price tag – you’ll be happy too. You can count on hours of fun with this toy, and your dog will never get tired of it.
Other Great Picks
Benebone Maplestick Durable Dog Chew Toy
The Benebone Maplestick Chew Toy is inspired by nature, giving your tough chewer ultimate satisfaction with REAL Maple Wood flavor…but this time, it’s indestructible! With 5 stars and nearly 2,000 glowing reviews, the Benebone Maplestick is a natural way to satisfy the needs to chew.
Titan Busy Bounce Tough Treat Dispensing Dog Toy
The Titan Busy Bounce Treat Dispensing Dog Toy is a durable, tough toy that can help with obedience training, crate training, and separation anxiety. Stuff the Titan Busy Bounce with dog treats and goodies so your pup can play and be stimulated, even while they are alone.
This interactive dog toy is made of FDA safe rubber that stands up to biting and teething with an erratic, fun bounce.
Monster K9 Indestructible Dog Frisbee
Who doesn’t like to play frisbee with their dog? Monster K9 has made frisbee a fun-loving, popular game amongst dogs with a habit of chewing. While a regular frisbee would crack and split, the Monster K9 Indestructible Dog Frisbee is a frisbee unlike any other.
Made from a unique rubber formula that compares to the strongest rubber compounds on Earth, the Monster K9 frisbee allows you to treat your pup to a classic game of frisbee without the worry.
Tuffy Mega Boomerang
Tuffy’s Mega Boomerang gives dogs the softness and warmth of a soft, fabric toy, but with the indestructible build. No more stuffing on the floor. Rated 10 on the TuffScale™, Tuffy’s dog toys are made for interactive play so the fun never stops.
The Mega Boomerang floats in water and is machine washable, so feel free to bring that toy wherever you go!
West Paw Zogoflex Rumpus Dog Chew Toy
The West Paw Zogoflex Rumpus Dog Chew Toy is designed for the heaviest of chewers with its three chew lobes to keep dogs engaged. This toy is also pretty versatile and can be played with in the water (it floats!).
A reliable brand, West Paw products are made in America, BPA-and-Phthalate-free, non-toxic, FDA compliant and dishwasher safe.
KONG Tires Extreme Dog Toy
The KONG Tires Extreme Dog Toy is a fun, unique toy that dogs love. With over 40 successful years in the pet industry market, KONG makes toys that allow for easy interactive play, satisfy instinctual needs, and keep heavy chewers busy.
The tire shape also allows for discreet treat stuffing and is easy to clean. A great pick.
Nylabone Durable Dentail Dinosaur Chew
The popular and affordable Nylabone Durable Dental Dinosaur Chew Toy serves more than one purpose. Not only can it withstand teething and biting, but it also promotes clean teeth with the raised nubs on the toy.
To make teeth cleaning fun, these Nylabone Dinosaurs are chicken-flavored and irresistible!
Nylabone Original Dura Chew Dog Chew
Nylabone has become a household name when it comes to dog toys. There are different types of Nylabone toys, but this Dura Chew Ring Dog Chew is a great option for the toughest of chewers and is designed for dogs anywhere from a puppy to 50+ pounds.
Wickedbone Smart Bone
A high-tech option for your best friend, the Wickedbone Smart Bone is an automatic and interactive toy for dogs (and cats!). With an app, you can control the dog toy or set auto-play modes.
Wickedbone acts responsively to different types of touch and has 12 types of emotional driven systems built-in. Fun for both you and your dog.
What Is An Indestructible Dog Toy?
Dogs are known to chew – it’s natural – and while some move past this habit as puppies, there are still many dogs who chew regularly, and usually, with more aggressive tendencies. Dog toys are well, made for dogs, but they aren’t always made for heavy chewers.
Indestructible dog toys are designed to withstand intense chewing and repetitive interactive playing without breaking, ripping, or falling apart because they are made from tough, resilient materials. Many indestructible dog toys aim to stimulate a dog’s mind by way of treat compartments and instinctive movement since lack of stimulation is a key cause of aggressive chewing.
What Are Indestructible Dog Toy Made Out Of?
You’ll find that many indestructible dog toys are made from tough, non-toxic, 100% FDA approved rubber that can withstand aggressive chewing and repetitive throwing. Indestructible dog toys are made with action and play in mind, and therefore, are also made with rubber that is easy to clean.
Some “soft” indestructible dog toys, like the Tuffy Mega Boomerang, are made with multiple layers of tough fabric and stitches, as well as protective webbing on the outside edge to ensure the stuffing stays inside of the toy and the stitches stay intact. Indestructible dog toys are built to last.
Can All Types Of Dogs Play With Indestructible Dog Toys?
Many indestructible dog toys can be used by any type of adult dog because of their neutral size. However, some dog toys are tailored to either a large dog or small dog. For example, KONG’s Extreme Dog toy is quite large and better suited for a larger dog, while the KONG tires are smaller and made for a small dog.
Rubber toys, like many on this indestructible dog toys list, are also great for teething puppies. Puppies do not know better when it comes to the right and wrong things to chew, so be sure to get your puppy one of these toys to keep them (and your shoes) safe.
What Are The Benefits Of Indestructible Dog Toys Over Fabric Dog Toys?
There are many benefits to choosing indestructible dog toys over standard or fabric dog toys and very few cons. To state a clear benefit, if the toy you choose for your pooch is indestructible, it will last longer, thus costing you less in the long run, resulting in less waste, and ensuring your dog’s toy is always intact, while fabric toys tend to rip apart and ruin fairly easily.
Dog toys that are long-lasting or indestructible are actually better for your dog’s health since their quality, resilient material should not break off and allow your dog to ingest the toy. Indestructible dog toys are also great for dog’s teeth, their mental stimulation, and coping with separation anxiety, frustration, and stress. Your dog gets stressed too!
Do Indestructible Dog Toys Squeak?
Some indestructible dog toys that are made from durable fabric have a squeaker, but many of the rubber-made toys are hollowed in order to be filled with treats. Squeakers are often a target for aggressive chewers, and because indestructible dog toys are designed with them in mind, squeakers are often left out.
If your pup responds to squeakers positively, look for “tough fabric” made toys that also have protective webbing and stitching. The extra measure to toughen up a fabric toy is necessary for its durability and lifespan.
Why Are Treat-Holding Dog Toys Popular?
Many think of toys that are designed to hold treats as a fun trick or puzzle for your dog. In reality, it’s actually a very healthy way to keep them mentally and physically stimulated as they are set up to retrieve the mysterious snack.
These toys are often indestructible and are really great tools for keeping your dog busy and minimizing destructive behavior when you don’t have a free hand to play.
How Do You Clean Dog Toys?
Let’s be honest, dogs can be a bit messy. So, it’s a good thing that indestructible dog toys are super easy to clean! In fact, indestructible dog toys that are made from rubber, are dishwasher safe. Fabric toys can be thrown in the washing machine and left to air dry.
If you do not have a dishwasher or washing machine, warm water and a bit of soap works well too. Especially if you are filling your dog’s toy with peanut butter or treats, you should clean the toy regularly to rid of any bacteria.
What Toys Should Aggressive Chewers Avoid?
If you know that your dog is a heavy chewer, there are some toys and materials that are better left at the pet store. Toys with squeakers, even ones that claim to be durable, usually have a very short lifespan with aggressive chewers, especially if left alone. Squeaking the toy isn’t the goal, getting the squeaker out is.
Plush, Fleece, Latex, and Vinyl toys are also not ideal for chewers. Toys made from plush and fleece are likely to tear while latex and vinyl toys are likely to break, creating sharp edges. These materials are simply not durable enough for dogs who love to chew.
How Much Do Indestructible Dog Toys Cost?
Indestructible dog toys are very affordable, even the larger toys. Prices range from $10 to $20 for standard rubber or fabric durable toys. Toys that are also considered a gadget or that have technological features to them may stretch a bit beyond $20, but still falling under $100.
Where Can I Buy Indestructible Dog Toys?
If you’d like to have a plethora of options ready and waiting, shopping online for indestructible dog toys is a great method. You can find nearly every brand and type of toy on the internet. If you’re keen on the in-store shopping experience, visit your favorite mom and pop pet or commercial pet store. All of these dog toys can be found on Amazon and most of them can be found in-store. Questionably inexpensive toys or unpopular knock-off brands may not be made out of the same high-quality, durable materials as the listed or well-known toy brands.
How Do I Choose The Best Indestructible Dog Toys For My Dog?
Does your dog have a tendency to rip squeakers out of toys? Do they love playing frisbee or solving puzzles? When looking for the best indestructible dog toy for your best friend, match your dog’s tactics with the promises of the new toy.
For dogs that love to shred fabric and take out squeakers, you should steer clear of fabric-bases or stitched toys. If your dog would get a kick out of searching for treats, if they love to get their repetitive chew on, a durable rubber toy or stick toy would serve them best…and last you the longest. Although indestructible dog toys are inexpensive, we still want you to purchase a toy that will last more than, well, a few hours. Think about the challenges you’ve had with toys in the past, and look for ones that will prevent those issues.
The Best Indestructible Dog Toys
There you have it – our picks for the best indestructible dog toys. Whether you just took your new puppy home or are used to your dog’s chewing habit, indestructible dog toys are a safe, reliable, inexpensive toy that will keep your dog entertained for years.
We’ve researched the best toys on the market so you and man’s best friend can live and play without stress. When looking for an indestructible dog toy, make sure the rubber is BPA-free and FDA approved with promises of durability.