How We Test
We aggregate millions of product reviews, scour other websites for their professional opinions - then we test the products ourselves. We do not accept free products from manufacturers, and our only goal is to give you the best recommendations possible. However, if you buy from the links on this page, we may earn a small commission.
- Best Probiotics - September 1, 2024
- Best Keto Snacks - September 1, 2024
- Instant Pot® Keto Birthday Cake - September 1, 2024
When it comes to having a baby, breastfeeding is an important activity – which definitely requires the best nipple cream. So we aggregated millions of actual customer reviews, scoured the internet for the top creams, and then rigorously tested the best ones to arrive at our top picks.
While you may not need a nipple cream if you are bottle feeding, most mothers like to breastfeed – making the best nipple cream absolutely essential. So without further adieu, here are our picks for the best nipple cream on the market today.
Our Top Pick
Lansinoh Lanolin Nipple Cream
This very affordable nipple cream is backed by thousands of five star reviews. We loved it during our testing, and its reputation speaks for itself.
Not only is this cream very affordable, it worked wonders for our chapped nipples. While you can certainly spend more, or go with an organic option – we think for most people, this is the perfect pick. Highly recommended.
Other Great Picks
Earth Mama Organic Nipple Butter
This nipple cream is USDA certified organic, and is made from only the highest quality ingredients. We loved how well it worked, and we also loved that it was made with top of the line ingredients.
It is also backed by thousands of stellar five star reviews, and while it costs slightly more than some options – we think the extra cost is definitely worth it. If you care a lot about what’s in your skincare products – this is definitely the right nipple cream for you.
Medela Lanolin Nipple Cream
This is another fantastic nipple cream, and it’s backed by thousands of great reviews. With a very low price point, it’s an affordable option for anyone.
It definitely helped make our nipples soft again, and we were impressed at how quickly it worked. Definitely another solid choice, and highly recommended.
Tiny Human Nipple Crack
This humorously named nipple cream definitely lives up to the hype. We loved how quickly and easily it brought our nipples back to normalcy, and how it kept our skin soft and smooth.
While it is slightly more expensive than some options out there, it is also made in the USA and certified organic – making the higher price tag worth it, in our opinion. It’s also backed by thousands of five star reviews, making this another great choice. Definitely recommended.
Bella B Nurturing Nipple Butter
This organic nipple cream is plant-based, and definitely worked wonders for our dry and puffy nipples. It’s also very easy to apply, and we found the smell somewhat soothing.
With a very low price for a formula that’s organic, this nipple butter is also backed by thousands of five star reviews. Another winner, and a product we were truly happy to test.
Mommy’s Bliss Lanolin Nipple Balm
This aptly titled nipple cream worked wonders for us, and we couldn’t be happier with the results. It offers smooth and safe protection, and the shea butter really moisturized our skin.
It’s also backed by a ton of perfect five star reviews, which made us feel comfortable buying the product. This is another choice moms can feel good about, and we highly recommend it.
Body Care By Weleda Nipple Balm
This is another great product, and one we loved testing. It made our skin feel moist and soft almost immediately, and we know other moms will have the same results.
You also do not need to remove the cream before breastfeeding, which was another factor that we loved. While it is slightly more than some solutions, we think it is well worth the extra cash.
The Honest Company Honest Mama Calm Your Nip Balm
The Honest Company is well known for only making products with the highest quality ingredients, and this nipple cream is no different. While it is slightly more expensive than some options, it is perfect for new mothers.
We found the high quality ingredients to be soothing and effective, though you certainly can get similar results for slightly less money. Ultimately though, if you care about high quality ingredients and the best possible products – this is (yet another) excellent choice.
Burt’s Bees Mama Soothing Nipple Cream
Burt’s Bees has a great reputation for making natural products, and this nipple cream is no exception. The coconut and vitamin E help make this cream very soothing, and we absolutely loved the fresh smell that came with it.
It also lacks all of the nasty chemicals that more artificial products contain, which should make all the eco warriors happy with this pick. We also enjoyed how soft our skin felt after we used it, so we highly recommend this product – we promise you won’t be disappointed.
Era Organics Soothing Nipple Cream
This certified organic nipple cream offers great protection against cracking and chafing, and helped make our nipples feel like new again. Being a new mom can be hard, but this nipple cream definitely made things a lot easier.
Backed by tons of five star reviews, we are far from the only ones who love this product. While it is slightly more expensive than some options, we think the extra cash is well worth it. Definitely recommended.
What Is Nipple Cream?
If you’ve ever breastfed, you likely know just how taxing a newborn baby can be on your delicate nipples. Chafing, inflammation, redness – none of these are pleasant. Nipple creams help to reduce these problems, and make your nipples feel soft and smooth again.
Do Nipple Creams Work?
If you have a dry and cracked area of skin, any moisturizing cream is likely to help it feel smoother and less irritated. In addition, nipple creams are specifically formulated for your breasts and nipples – making them even more effective.
How Often Should I Apply Nipple Cream?
The manufacturer’s instructions for nipple cream will usually state that once daily is ideal. However, in our experience, you will likely want to apply nipple cream as often as needed.
If you are very sore and chapped, and waited a long time to actually buy nipple cream – it’s highly likely that you will need to use it more than once a day, at least in the beginning. We sometimes found ourselves applying the cream 4-5 times per day – so your own mileage may vary.
What Is Wrong With Lanolin Nipple Cream?
While lanolin has been used for thousands of years, it can cause an allergic reaction in a very small portion of the population. If you have a known allergy to wool, lanolin based products may not be for you.
However, even if you do not have this allergy, if you develop allergy-like symptoms after using a nipple cream with lanolin – discontinue using it. There are plenty of alternatives out there for new mothers, and the lanolin allergy is why so many different organic and alternative nipple cream products have come to the marketplace.
Is Nipple Cream Useful?
This one is a resounding ‘yes’. Consider yourself lucky, if you’ve never struggled with dry and/or chapped nipples.
For those moms that have, it’s not hard to know why nipple creams are extremely useful. Chapped and red nipples immediately become soothed and smooth, once the right nipple cream is applied.
Since the process of being a new mom is already hard enough, the right nipple cream is akin to a godsend. Some products will be lanolin-free, as a very small portion of consumers has an allergy to sheep (or wool).
More natural products usually contain ingredients like coconut oil, shea butter, or beeswax. In fact, there is really an unlimited amount of natural compounds that may work for soothing skin, without being as likely to provoke an allergic reaction.
Just like you would deal with eczema with the right creams and medicines, dry and chapped nipples deserve the same level of treatment and care. Breastfeeding moms have it bad enough already, they don’t need more to deal with – including dry and red nipples.
In some moms, the chafing and dryness becomes so bad that they can’t deal with it anymore. Newborn babies are usually quite hungry, so things are not always easy for the new moms out there.
Other Buying Factors For The Best Nipple Cream
There are many different factors when considering which nipple cream to buy. For starters, you may prefer natural ingredients (or even organic ingredients) – things like calendula, coconut oil, beeswax, marshmallow root, cocoa butter, and products which are cruelty-free, lanolin-free, and made with no additives or parabens.
Another issue may be for those with dry skin. While generally all nipple creams are hydrating, those with pre-existing dry skin may need lotions that are extra nourishing.
You may also care about hypoallergenic solutions, or an organic nipple balm, for your sore nipples. Amazon alone has millions of different options, and for those with sensitive skin you may even need an unscented nipple cream, completely without preservatives.
In situations like this, sometimes extra virgin olive oil, or calendula flower may be added as soothing ingredients. When it comes to the best nipple creams for breastfeeding, any of the choices on our list will allow you to use a breast pump to make great breast milk – or allow you to breastfeed directly.
Many consumers will care about products that have no gluten, and that are also non-GMO. While your little one may not know the difference, natural nipple cream may have some additional benefits for your skin.
Nipple pain is one of the worst things imaginable, so the best nipple creams can definitely be a lifesaver. We looked at products by companies who already make great lip balms and salves, with the hope that their expertise would likely transfer over.
You may also be worried about allergens, so nursing bras can help, along with nursing pads and the right (maybe medical-grade) nursing balms. The best organic nipple creams won’t irritate your skin, so be sure to look carefully at any ingredient lists, if you have sensitive skin and/or boobs.
Another problem that isn’t a lot of fun, is diaper rash, so be sure to carry the right products in your diaper bag, for cracked skin – whether it’s yours or your baby’s. Breastfeeding moms definitely need a lot more accessories and products than the average mom, so be sure that you also meet with a lactation consultant.
Even simple things like aloe or mango butter may make your life a heck of a lot easier, so be sure you don’t limit yourself to too few products. Brands like Bamboobies, Medela Tender Care, and Motherlove Nipple Cream all offer excellent options.
Nipple nurture is another name for nipple cream, and there are countless ingredients that can be helpful for new moms. Sunflower oil, sheep’s wool, and many other things can all help soothe sore and red nipples.
As lanolin has become slightly less popular, more and more consumers have started turning to organic ingredients in their nipple creams. While we personally have no adverse reaction to lanolin, it is important to know that there are many alternatives out there.
The Best Nipple Cream
There you have it – our picks for the best nipple cream on the market today. When you have a baby, the last thing you’re likely thinking about is your nipples – but trust us, you’ll want the best nipple cream.
When it came time to review nipple creams, we looked at price, customer reviews, and much more. We found that there were many great options out there, and that it really came down to personal preference.
Any of the ten choices on our list will make for a great choice when it comes to picking a nipple cream – ultimately it just comes down to what you are specifically looking for. And if you liked this review, be sure to check out some of our other best product reviews.